Research finding · November 2026
Feelings of defeat and entrapment may contribute to suicidal thoughts among sexual and gender minority adults
Sexual and gender minority (SGM) people (i.e., including lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, nonbinary, and other people whose sexual orientation or gender identity differs from the majority) experience higher rates of suicidal thoughts and behaviors than cisgender heterosexual people. Research suggests that this disparity is shaped in part by experiences such as discrimination, stigma, rejection, and other forms of minority stress, rather than by SGM identity itself. One framework used to understand how suicidal thoughts develop is the Integrated Motivational-Volitional model, which highlights two psychological experiences: defeat (i.e., feeling overwhelmed by failure, struggle, or loss) and entrapment (i.e., feeling a strong desire to escape while seeing no way out). Both have been linked to suicidal thoughts and behaviors across many populations, but less is known about whether these experiences operate differently for SGM adults, whose broader social environments may add additional sources of stress or support.
With her AFSP grant, Dr. Amy Brausch examined these relationships in two adult samples: 865 college students in the United States and 734 adults in the United Kingdom. In both groups, SGM participants were more likely than cisgender heterosexual participants to report a history of suicidal thoughts, and higher levels of both defeat and entrapment were associated with suicidal ideation. In the U.S. sample, the link between entrapment and suicidal ideation was especially strong among SGM participants. That pattern did not appear in the U.K. sample, where suicidal thoughts were common across both SGM and cisgender heterosexual participants. The researchers note that the U.K. sample was generally at higher risk, which may have made differences between groups harder to see. The findings suggest that defeat and entrapment may be important pathways to suicidal distress across groups. Larger longitudinal studies are needed to clarify how shared psychological risk factors and identity-specific stressors interact over time.
Citation: Amy M. Brausch, Taylor Kalgren, Seonaid Cleare , Kirsty Clark & Rory C. O’Connor (02 Sep 2026): Suicide Risk in Adults: The Roles of Defeat, Entrapment, and Sexual and Gender Minority Identity Across Two Samples, Archives of Suicide Research, https://doi.org/10.1080/13811118.2026.2724116
This finding comes from an AFSP-funded study — see the grant below ↓